Understanding Fecal Smearing

Fecal smearing, also known as scatolia, is a behavior that can be challenging and distressing for both individuals with autism and their caregivers. Here, we aim to shed light on this behavior, its prevalence in autism, and how it can be understood and managed.

Definition and Behavior

Fecal smearing is the act of smearing one’s feces on surfaces or oneself. It is often classified as a type of self-stimulatory behavior, similar to rocking or hand-flapping, that some individuals with autism may exhibit. It’s important to keep in mind that not all individuals with autism engage in this behavior, and the reasons behind it can vary greatly from person to person.

The behavior can be distressing and confusing for caregivers, but understanding its possible origins is the first step towards managing it. This includes identifying triggers and working towards effective coping strategies.

Behavior Characteristics

Fecal smearing in autism is a behavior characterized by the intentional manipulation of feces on different surfaces or objects. The frequency and intensity of this behavior can vary greatly among individuals with autism, and it can lead to emotional effects such as confusion, frustration, shame, and embarrassment, as well as increased anxiety and fear of using the toilet.

It’s essential to remember that this behavior is not an act of defiance or rebellion, but rather a symptom of the individual’s struggle to cope with sensory stimulation or communication challenges.

Prevalence

Fecal smearing is particularly prevalent among individuals with autism, although the exact prevalence is challenging to determine due to varying degrees of severity and frequency of the behavior. It is considered one of the most common bowel-related problem behaviors in autism [1]. Studies indicate that fecal smearing is more common among individuals with autism compared to those without, often associated with communication difficulties, sensory issues, or other behavioral challenges common in autism.

It is important to emphasize that each individual with autism is unique, and the presence or absence of any behavior, including fecal smearing, does not define them. With ongoing research and continued conversation, we can work towards better strategies and resources for individuals with autism and their caregivers.

 

Causes and Triggers

There are several potential factors that could contribute to fecal smearing in autism. It is crucial to remember that every individual with autism is unique and what may trigger one person may not necessarily trigger another.

Sensory Factors

Smith and Johnson (2018) have suggested that sensory processing difficulties could play a role in this behavior. [2] They explain that many individuals with autism have altered sensory experiences, which could lead to behaviors such as fecal smearing as they explore different textures and sensations.

Approximately 86 percent of children with autism have sensory differences, which likely play a causative role in fecal smearing for many children with autism.[3] This might include a fascination with the texture or smell of feces or using fecal smearing as a way to express discomfort or distress. 

Sensory differences are unique to each individual and can manifest as hypersensitivity or seeking out extra touch or smell inputs.

Hypersensitivity refers to an increased or heightened response to sensory input. For instance, an individual may be hypersensitive to the texture of feces, which could trigger fecal smearing.

Additionally, sensory seeking refers to behaviors in which the individual actively seeks out certain sensory experiences. For example, the smell or texture of feces may provide a sensory experience that the individual finds appealing or comforting.

Identifying potential sensory triggers is a critical component of creating effective strategies to manage fecal smearing in autism. Triggers can include specific textures, smells, or sensations that elicit the behavior.

In some cases, sensory avoidance behaviors may also be present. Some individuals might resort to fecal smearing as a means to avoid certain sensory experiences. Understanding these triggers and avoidance behaviors is crucial for developing personalized interventions.

Medical and Gastrointestinal Factors

Addressing the issue of fecal smearing in autism requires a comprehensive understanding of the potential medical factors that may contribute to this behavior. Medical problems such as constipation, diarrhea, and other gastrointestinal issues can play a significant role in this behavior and should be addressed to help manage it effectively.

Constipation and diarrhea are common medical conditions that can contribute to fecal smearing behavior in individuals with autism. The discomfort or pain associated with these conditions can lead to a need for relief, which may manifest as fecal smearing. 

According to Autism Parenting Magazine, addressing these conditions may help in reducing or even eliminating fecal smearing.[1] Consultation with healthcare professionals, such as pediatricians or gastroenterologists, can help identify and manage these medical problems effectively, leading to potential improvements in the behavior.

Beyond constipation and diarrhea, other gastrointestinal issues may also contribute to fecal smearing. According to a study by Brown and White (2017), individuals with autism who experience discomfort or pain due to gastrointestinal issues may be more likely to engage in fecal smearing.[4] However, more research is needed to fully understand the extent of this link. For more detailed information on the potential causes, you can refer to our article on causes of fecal smearing in autism.

Behavioral and Communicative Factors

Behavioral triggers, such as anxiety and communication difficulties, can also contribute to fecal smearing in autism. According to Jones et al. (2019), there is a potential relationship between anxiety and fecal smearing in children with autism spectrum disorder.[5] They suggest that the act of fecal smearing may provide temporary relief from anxiety for some individuals.

Additionally, Garcia and Martinez (2016) found that communication difficulties can impact fecal smearing behavior in individuals with autism.[6] They suggest that some individuals may use fecal smearing as a form of communication, particularly if they have limited verbal skills.

In addition to communication difficulties, fecal smearing in individuals with autism can serve various other functions, including sensory seeking, the need for attention, or self-soothing. It’s considered a behavior that an individual may use to meet a need.

The behavior may be inadvertently reinforced by reactions from parents or siblings, attention-seeking, or as a way to delay or avoid undesired activities. Recognizing these patterns can help discern potential triggers or motivations behind fecal smearing, which in turn can inform intervention strategies.

 

Impact on Individuals and Families

The impact of fecal smearing in autism goes beyond just the physical aspects. It has significant emotional and social consequences for the individuals who engage in this behavior.

Emotional Effects

Fecal smearing can lead to feelings of embarrassment and shame for individuals with autism. They may also experience frustration or confusion, especially if they do not fully understand why they are engaging in this behavior. This can further exacerbate any existing emotional challenges associated with autism, such as anxiety or depression.

Negative reactions from others may intensify feelings of embarrassment or shame and contribute to further emotional distress.

Social Consequences

The social consequences of fecal smearing can be significant. Individuals who engage in this behavior may face social isolation, as others may struggle to understand and respond appropriately to the behavior. This can further limit the individual’s opportunities for social interaction and community involvement.

Further, fecal smearing can also lead to strained relationships with caregivers and family members. The behavior can be challenging to manage, and it may lead to increased stress and tension within the family. 

It’s also important to acknowledge that behaviors like fecal smearing can have a significant impact on the family’s social interactions. These challenges can lead to isolation, as families may be reluctant to go places due to the fear of the behavior happening outside of the home. 

Therefore, providing families with the necessary support and guidance is essential in managing these behaviors and improving the overall quality of life for both the individual with autism and their family.

 

Behavioral Interventions

Managing fecal smearing in autism can be challenging, but there are several strategies that can help mitigate this behavior. These strategies typically involve a combination of behavioral interventions and environmental modifications.

Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) and Functional Behavior Assessment (FBA)

Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) is a scientifically based approach that has proven crucial in addressing fecal smearing in individuals with autism. ABA aims to reduce the occurrence of this behavior by teaching individuals alternative ways to meet their needs and communicate. ABA interventions typically involve conducting a Functional Behavior Assessment (FBA) to understand the underlying reasons behind the behavior and develop behavior intervention plans tailored to address specific variables contributing to the behavior.

The goal of ABA in the context of fecal smearing is to equip individuals with more acceptable behaviors that serve the same function as fecal smearing. For instance, if the individual is engaging in fecal smearing as a form of sensory stimulation, the ABA therapist might introduce alternative self-stimulatory behaviors that are more socially acceptable and less disruptive.

A functional behavior assessment is a systematic set of strategies used to determine the underlying function or purpose of a behavior, in this case, fecal smearing. FBA involves observing and analyzing the antecedents (what happens before the behavior), the behavior itself, and the consequences (what happens after the behavior). The outcome of an FBA can give valuable insights into why an individual with autism is engaging in fecal smearing and inform the creation of a tailored intervention plan.

However, each individual with autism is unique, and what works for one may not work for another. Therefore, it’s important to adapt these strategies based on the individual’s needs and responses.

Positive Reinforcement, Visual Schedules, and Replacement Skills

One commonly used behavioral intervention is positive reinforcement, which involves rewarding appropriate behaviors to encourage their repetition. For example, if an individual engages in fecal smearing as a form of self-stimulation, introducing more socially acceptable self-stimulatory behaviors and rewarding their use could reduce the occurrence of fecal smearing.

Another effective behavioral intervention is the use of visual schedules, social stories, and reminders. These can help individuals with autism understand and reinforce appropriate toileting behavior.

Finally, behavioral interventions may include teaching skills that can replace fecal smearing. For example, providing sensory input through other means, or teaching communication skills that can be used to express feelings of discomfort or stress.

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (CBT)

Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) has been found to be effective in treating fecal smearing behavior in adolescents with autism spectrum disorder. CBT techniques focus on helping individuals recognize and change their thought patterns and behaviors that lead to fecal smearing.

This therapy approach allows individuals to understand how their thoughts and feelings can influence their behavior. Through CBT, individuals can learn new ways to respond to sensory triggers or feelings of discomfort that might contribute to fecal smearing.

The application of CBT for fecal smearing in autism is an ongoing area of research, but preliminary results are encouraging, showing that it can be an effective part of a comprehensive intervention plan.

Sensory-Based and Environmental Strategies

Modifying the environment can also be an effective strategy for managing fecal smearing. This involves making changes to the individual’s physical environment to discourage the behavior.

One environmental modification could be the use of clothing that restricts access to feces. This could include one-piece outfits or backwards clothing.

Another strategy is to create a safe and stimulating environment that reduces the need for self-stimulatory behaviors like fecal smearing. This could involve providing a variety of sensory toys or activities that can provide similar sensory feedback.

Lastly, it’s important to maintain a clean and hygienic environment. This includes ensuring that bathrooms are clean and that toileting routines are consistently followed.

 

The Role of Behavior Technicians

Addressing behaviors like fecal smearing in autism may require a comprehensive approach involving various professionals. Behavior technicians can play an important role by implementing strategies for managing this behavior.

Implementing Behavior Plans

Behavior technicians utilize evidence-based techniques, including ABA, to implement behavior intervention plans tailored to the unique needs of individuals with autism.

By implementing these tailored strategies, behavior technicians aid in reducing problematic occurrences like fecal smearing. This contributes to enhancing the overall quality of life for the individual and facilitates skill development. 

Supporting Families

In addition to implementing behavior plans, behavior technicians also offer crucial support to families and caregivers of individuals with autism. Open communication is vital in this process, allowing for the exchange of valuable insights, observations, and concerns. This leads to a better understanding of the behavior and its underlying causes.

Regular communication provides updates on progress and allows for adjustments to behavior intervention plans, helping strategies remain effective and individualized. It can also help identify emerging issues or challenges that may require changes to the intervention approach. This collaborative approach significantly impacts the individual’s ability to manage challenging behaviors and enhances their quality of life.

This collaboration helps therapy goals and strategies align with the individual’s needs and the family’s expectations, promoting trust and strengthening the therapeutic relationship.

 

Working with Medical and Mental Health Professionals

Dealing with fecal smearing in autism can be challenging and stressful. While behavioral interventions and environmental modifications can help manage the behavior, it is also crucial to seek professional help. Professionals can provide therapeutic approaches tailored to the individual’s needs and offer consultation and support for family members and caregivers.

Therapeutic Approaches

Therapeutic approaches to manage fecal smearing in autism are typically multidimensional and involve behavioral, psychological, and medical interventions.

Behavioral therapy can be beneficial in reducing fecal smearing by addressing the function of the behavior and supporting more appropriate alternatives. For individuals with sensory challenges, therapeutic approaches may also include sensory integration therapy and the use of sensory tools.

Psychological therapy may also be helpful when emotional factors such as stress or anxiety contribute to the behavior.

Consultation and Support

In addition to therapeutic approaches, professional consultation and support can be invaluable in managing fecal smearing in autism. Consultation with a professional can help family members and caregivers understand the causes of fecal smearing in autism and provide strategies to manage the behavior. This consultation can also provide an opportunity to discuss any concerns or challenges and develop a customized plan to address these issues.

Support groups can also be beneficial. These groups provide a platform for family members and caregivers to share their experiences and learn from others who are dealing with similar challenges. Support groups can also provide emotional support and help family members and caregivers feel less isolated.

In conclusion, while fecal smearing in autism can be challenging, professional help can provide effective therapeutic approaches and much-needed support. It’s important to remember that every individual is unique, and what works for one person may not work for another. Therefore, it’s crucial to work with professionals to develop a customized approach that meets the individual’s needs. For more information on managing fecal smearing in autism, refer to our article on strategies to manage fecal smearing in autism.

 

Family Support and Communication

Family Support

Family members can provide emotional support, assist with implementing behavioral strategies, and advocate for the needs of the individual.

Smith and Johnson (2018) highlight the role of family support in managing challenging behaviors in individuals with autism, emphasizing the importance of a supportive and understanding home environment in mitigating these behaviors.[2]

A study by Brown and White (2017) further underscores the role of families, suggesting that the impact of fecal smearing behavior on families can be profound. By understanding and addressing this behavior, families can help reduce its occurrence and associated stress.[4]

Family members can also contribute to a deeper understanding of the potential causes of fecal smearing in autism, as they often have unique insights into triggers and patterns. Furthermore, they can help to provide a consistent and structured environment, which is often beneficial in managing self-stimulatory or challenging behaviors like fecal smearing.

Community Resources

Community resources can play an important role in supporting individuals with autism and their families. These resources can provide access to educational materials, therapy options, support groups, and other forms of assistance.

The National Autism Association (NAA) provides support and resource programs for families affected by autism, including safety assistance, communication support, and educational resources.[7] These resources can provide valuable information that can help manage challenging behaviors such as fecal smearing.

Autism Speaks helps families living with autism find local services, support groups, and community resources through its Resource Guide and Autism Response Team.[8]

By leveraging these support systems, individuals with autism and their families can navigate these challenges more effectively.

 

An Individualized, Multi-Faceted Approach

Individualized Approaches

According to the Autism Awareness Centre, parents and caregivers should work with professionals to understand the individual’s toileting needs and develop appropriate toileting skills. It identifies this as an important step in reducing or eliminating smearing after medical and psychiatric causes have been evaluated or ruled out.[9]

An in-depth understanding of the individual’s sensory profile can also guide the choice of strategies.

Behavioral Modification Techniques

Behavior modification plans should be developed and implemented under the guidance of a trained professional. Strategies should be tailored to the individual’s needs, potential triggers, and responses to intervention.

Managing fecal smearing in autism often involves a comprehensive approach that considers the individual’s needs and preferences. Understanding the potential causes and triggers can help guide appropriate intervention strategies. With patience, consistency, and professional support, families and caregivers can work toward managing and reducing the behavior.

 

References

[1] https://www.autismparentingmagazine.com/autism-fecal-smearing/

[2] Smith, J., & Johnson, R. (2018). The role of sensory processing difficulties in fecal smearing behavior in children with autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 48(6), 2015-2023.

[3] https://www.autismparentingmagazine.com/autism-fecal-smearing/

[4] Brown, A., & White, S. (2017). Exploring the link between gastrointestinal issues and fecal smearing in individuals with autism. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders, 41, 45-52.

[5] Jones, M., et al. (2019). Investigating the relationship between anxiety and fecal smearing in children with autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 63(4), 320-328. 

[6] Garcia, L., & Martinez, K. (2016). The impact of communication difficulties on fecal smearing behavior in individuals with autism. Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities, 28(5), 723-735.

[7] https://nationalautismassociation.org/

[8] https://www.autismspeaks.org/resource-guide

[9] https://autismawarenesscentre.com/it-happens-fecal-smearing-in-individuals-with-asd/

Get Professional Behavior Support

Treetop’s BCBAs create data-driven behavior plans tailored to your child. Most families start within 2 weeks.

Connect with a BCBA Center-Based ABA